Idk if anyone agrees, but I think she could’ve been really good.
It’s just so improbable that this topic wouldn’t be brought up even once, in all those conversations Harry had with Sirius and Remus. If Harry ever wanted to know more about Lily, Snape being a part of her life would’ve been a big, although unpleasant, topic to mention. I know their friendship and Snape’s love was intentionally kept secret until The Prince’s Tale, but it’s just so illogical.
I’ve never had a close family. I’ve never had a family that would do anything for the rest of their family. I’m also a very opinionated person and if I don’t agree with something I won’t support it. I understand that Draco did everything for his family and while I do commend him for his actions, I would never do it myself.
It really shouldn’t matter what the covers of the books look like or whether or not it should be “Sorcerer” or “Philosopher” on the first book. What really matters is what’s on the inside, the amazing story that brought all of us together. All this fighting is just breaking apart the fandom. Can’t we all just agree to disagree?
The part where he said “You seem to have a bit of a security problem.” was the most. freaking. epic. thing. EVER.
“Time is making fools of us again.”
~Albus Percival Wulfric Brian Dumbledore
Out of all four Marauders, we knew the least about James life, whether it was his school life or his childhood. You have no idea what he might of or might have not gone through because Jo never gave us details. Don’t assume just because he was never spoken about that he had a perfect life. He wasn’t the only one bullying Severus, there were four Marauders, not just James. I don’t see any hate for Remus and I know he didn’t particularly join in on the bullying but he never stopped it or stopped James and Sirius yet no one bothers to pick up on this. We hardly know anything about their era so we should stop assuming that James’ hate for Severus was one sided because if I remember correctly, Severus tried to hex him and the others every chance he got as well and wasn’t a helpless victim.
i think towards the end, JK Rowling only wrote the books for the film not for the storey.